 Gluten Sensitivity Neuropathy (Celiac Disease)
This is a proposed autoimmune disorder induced by celiac disease.
Wheat, barley, and oats are
composed of gluten that may induce an antibody reaction in
susceptible individuals.
These
antibodies are thought to be directed against Purkinje cells and
other nervous system tissue
leading to a variety of disorders including cerebellar ataxia,
neuropathy, and myoclonus.
Symptoms
. These included ataxia (difficulty walking)
Peripheral neuropathy (burning pain and numbness)
Myopathy (weakness of hips)
Ataxia with myoclonus (Jerking in legs with difficult in keeping
balance)
Myelopathy (weakness of legs),
Dementia (Memory disorder)
.
The same author has reported
up to 40% of patients with idiopathic peripheral neuropathy have
anti-gliadin antibodies
(Hadjivassiliou, 2002).
The neuromuscular manifestations include sensorimotor axonal
neuropathy, axonal motor, and
mononeuropathy multiplex. All patients were found to have anti-gliadin
antibodies, either IgG or
IgA. Of all patients with positive antibodies, only 35% have an
abnormal intestinal biopsy,
suggesting that neurologic symptoms may occur without GI symptoms. HLA DQ2 is found in
90% of patients with celiac disease so this offers an additional
confirmatory test. Further study is
needed of this potentially important cause of neurologic illness.
Cobalamin deficiency or Vitamin B-12 deficiency may be caused by a number of malabsorption
syndromes, most commonly
pernicious anemia, which accounts for well over 80% of all cases of
B-12 deficiency. In up to
10% of patients, the cobalamin deficiency may be due to food
cobalamin malabsorption, which
results from achlorhydria and an inability to separate cobalamin
from food due to inadequate
gastric acidity. A number of other malabsorptive syndromes of the
lower gut, such as bacterial
overgrowth, tapeworm infestation, Crohn's disease, and ulcerative
colitis, may also result in
cobalamin deficiency (Green and Kinsella 1995; Savage and Lindenbaum
1995).
Post gastroplasty neuropathy and Strachan's syndrome remain a
mystery in terms of the exact
etiology but are probably polynutritional in origin, with a heavy
emphasis on thiamin deficiency.
Vitamin B-6 or Pyridoxine excess
Toxic doses of pyridoxine may also result in a large fiber sensory
peripheral neuropathy
(Schaumburg et al 1983; Parry and Bredesen 1985; Dalton and Dalton
1987). Mega doses of
pyridoxine may produce a sensory neuropathy after several weeks of
use, generally in excess of 2
grams per day. It has also been reported with longstanding use of as
little as 200 mg a day.
Symptoms of paresthesias, ataxia, and burning feet occur 1 month to
3 years after starting
pyridoxine.
Axonal degeneration, reduced myelin fiber density, and myelin debris
have all been demonstrated
in sural nerve biopsies.
After stopping the pyridoxine, few patients
entirely resolved, but most
improved. Individuals who use large doses of B-complex vitamins are
under the false impression
that, because B-complex vitamins are water soluble and, therefore,
are excreted in the urine, it is
not possible to take too much. In fact, 200 mg doses of pyridoxine
are commonly found as
single tablets in pharmacies and are sufficient to cause a sensory
neuropathy after many months
of exposure.
Strachan's syndrome
In 1888, Henry Strachan, a British medical officer stationed in
Jamaica, described a syndrome of
painful peripheral neuropathy, ataxia, optic neuropathy, and
stomatitis among sugarcane workers
(Strachan 1897). Denny Brown and others found similar ailments among
allied troops liberated
from prisoner of war camps after World War II (Denny-Brown 1947).
Other symptoms included
sensorineural deafness, dizziness, confusion, spastic leg weakness,
foot drop, Wernicke's
encephalopathy, and rare cases of neck extensor weakness and
myasthenic bulbar weakness. Poor
nutrition, hard physical labor, and concurrent infection were
thought to be exacerbating factors.
Fischer performed autopsies on a series of Canadian prisoners of
war, the most prominent
pathologic findings were demyelination of the posterior columns of
thoracic and cervical spinal
cord (Fischer 1955).
More recently, an outbreak of optic and peripheral neuropathy
closely resembling Strachan's
syndrome occurred in Cuba from 1992 to 1993 following a loss of food
and fuel imports from
the former Soviet Union (Roman 1994). Fifty thousand people
developed either isolated or
combined optic neuropathy, painful sensory neuropathy, dorsal
lateral myelopathy, sensory neural
deafness, spastic paraparesis, dysphonia, and dysautonomia. Forty-
five percent developed
centrocecal scotoma and optic neuropathy only, often following a
period of weight loss. A
number of possibilities were proposed, including vitamin B-complex
and thiamin deficiency,
cyanide intoxication, viral infections, and mitochondrial deletions.
Heavy alcohol and tobacco use
were found most frequently in those with optic neuropathy
(tobacco-alcohol amblyopia). Clinical
evidence of neuropathy was often lacking despite the severe symptoms
(Thomas et al 1995).
Sural nerve biopsy showed axonal degeneration of large myelinated
fibers. Most patients
responded to supplementation of B-complex vitamins.
Vitamin E deficiency
Vitamin E is fat soluble and found in abundance in vegetable oils
and wheat germ. It is carried
in portal blood to the liver, and alpha- tocopherol transfer protein
binds it and recycles vitamin E
in the liver for incorporation into low density and very low density
lipoproteins. The patients at
risk for development of vitamin E deficiency include those with hypo
or abetalipoproteinemia,
other disorders of the pancreas and liver, such as cystic fibrosis,
protein-calorie malnutrition,
familial vitamin E deficiency, and other malabsorption states
(Jackson et al 1996). Symptoms
include areflexia, cerebellar ataxia, cutaneous sensory impairment,
position and vibratory sense
abnormalities and less commonly, ophthalmoplegia, muscle weakness,
nystagmus, extensor plantar
responses, ptosis, and dysarthria. The peripheral neuropathy is
usually limited to the legs and is
mild, axonal, and sensorimotor in nature (Brin et al 1986).
13. Diagnostic Evaluation
Thiamin deficiency may be assessed by the transketolase assay.
Because the carbohydratemetabolizing
enzyme transketolase requires thiamin pyrophosphate, a deficiency
will lead to an
elevation in the red blood cell transketolase. The assay is most
sensitive when performed with
and without a thiamin pyrophosphate challenge. Serum thiamin levels
are unreliable due to low
sensitivity and specificity. MRI of the brain will occasionally show
an abnormal signal in the
periaqueductal gray matter and midline structures.
Cobalamin deficiency may be due to a variety of disorders, most
commonly pernicious anemia. Approximately 78% of patients with cobalamin deficiency will be
found to have a proven or
probable defect of intrinsic factor production from the gastric
parietal cell (pernicious anemia).
Perhaps 10% of patients have food-cobalamin malabsorption due to
hypo- or achlorhydria, a
disorder that affects from 16-40% of the elderly ( Hurwitz et al,
1997). The rest are due to a
variety of causes including malabsorption from inflammatory bowel
disease, tape worm
infestation, blind loop syndrome, chronic H2 blocker therapy,
gastric bypass, and serum binding
protein abnormalities.
In a patient with signs and symptoms of cobalamin deficiency, one
should begin with a
cobalamin assay. If the serum cobalamin assay result is less than
the lower normal limit, a
measurement of intrinsic factor antibodies should be taken. If this
test is positive, the diagnosis of
pernicious anemia is confirmed, and a Schilling test is not
necessary. In pernicious anemia, some
laboratory evidence of an autoimmune process is often found. Anti-
parietal cell antibodies are
present in 90% and intrinsic factor antibodies in 60% of patients
with pernicious anemia. Antiparietal cell antibodies have a 10% false positive rate. Though
it lacks sensitivity, the test for intrinsic factor antibodies is much more specific.
In patients with serum cobalamin levels in the lower normal range,
but in whom one still
suspects clinical cobalamin deficiency, one should measure levels of
homocysteine and
methylmalonic acid (Snow, 1999; Kinsella and Green, 1995).
Methylmalonic acid may be
measured in serum or urine. The urinary assay is more specific in
patients with renal
insufficiency. If either metabolite is elevated, then serum
intrinsic factor antibodies and gastrin
should be measured. The serum gastrin level is often elevated in
pernicious anemia and is a
marker for achlorhydria, a cause of food- cobalamin malabsorption.
The presence of hypersegmentation may be a sensitive marker for
cobalamin deficiency, even in
the absence of anemia or macrocytosis. If metabolites or the serum
gastrin are elevated, a
Schilling test may be performed to identify cobalamin absorption,
which is usually the result of
autoimmune parietal cell dysfunction that occurs in pernicious
anemia. Technically, patients with
classic pernicious anemia have an abnormal test result when
radioactive cobalamin alone is given
by mouth (Part I). This abnormality is corrected when the test is
repeated with intrinsic factor
(Part II). Abnormally low secretion of cobalamin in the Part II
Schilling test indicates an
intestinal cause for the cobalamin malabsorption, such as
inflammatory bowel disease. The Part II
Schilling test may be repeated, after giving antibiotics or
vermacides to exclude bacterial
overgrowth ("blind loop syndrome") or fish tapeworm infestation due
to diphyllobothrium latum,
rare causes of cobalamin deficiency through competition for
intraluminal cobalamin.
A normal Part I test in a patient with cobalamin deficiency may be
observed in total vegetarians.
It may also occur in patients with food-cobalamin malabsorption who
show normal absorption of
crystalline cobalamin but are unable to digest and absorb cobalamin
present in food due to
achlorhydria. This defect can be identified using a modified
Schilling test in which radioactive
cobalamin is administered with food (Carmel, 1990).
Pyridoxine deficiency will cause elevations in serum homocysteine
and cystathionine, and assays
are commercially available. Urinary assays for xanthurenic acid and
other pyridoxine metabolites
may be performed following tryptophan loading.
Vitamin E deficiency can be reliably investigated using the serum
alpha- tocopherol level. Adult
patients without malabsorption and a clinical picture consistent
with Friedrich’s ataxia and
neuropathy should be investigated for an autosomal recessive defect
in the tocopherol transporter
protein gene of chromosome 8. Tocopherol transporter protein
incorporates tocopherol into
chylomicrons. The serum tocopherol levels in these patients may be
in the normal range;
however, they respond to high dose supplementation.
Strachan’s syndrome and are polynutritional in origin; therefore, a
battery of vitamin deficiencies
should be sought, including thiamin, niacin, pyridoxine, and
cobalamin. The pathophysiology of
post-gastroplasty neuropathy is probably multifactorial, due perhaps
to a polynutritional and an
endogenous toxin produced as the result of the abnormal anatomy
created by the surgical
procedure. This toxic hypothesis is supported by the fact that some
have reported a resolution of
the symptoms following reversal of the surgical procedure whereas
nutritional replacement alone
does not. Alternatively, there may be a nutritional factor that
cannot be replaced adequately until
the procedure has been reversed.Pyridoxine deficiency will cause
elevations in serum homocysteine and cystathionine, and assays
are commercially available. Urinary assays for xanthurenic acid and
other pyridoxine metabolites
may be performed following tryptophan loading.
Vitamin E deficiency can be reliably investigated using the serum
alpha- tocopherol level. Adult
patients without malabsorption and a clinical picture consistent
with Friedrich’s ataxia and
neuropathy should be investigated for an autosomal recessive defect
in the tocopherol transporter
protein gene of chromosome 8. Tocopherol transporter protein
incorporates tocopherol into
chylomicrons. The serum tocopherol levels in these patients may be
in the normal range;
however, they respond to high dose supplementation.
~15.
Management
Treatment of suspected thiamine deficiency in the setting of
post-gastroplasty neuropathy,
Strachan’s syndrome, or Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome begins with
the immediate administration
of 100 mg thiamine intravenously followed by 100 mg
intramuscularly daily for 3 to 5 days and
parenteral multivitamins. Patients are then maintained on 50 mg
thiamin orally along with
multivitamins daily.
For cobalamin deficiency, the total body store of cobalamin is
2000 to 5000 μg, half of which is
stored in the liver. The recommended daily allowance is 6 μg/day,
and the average diet provides
20 μg/day. Treatment may begin with intramuscular injections of
1000 μg of cobalamin for 5
days, then 500 to 1000 μg intramuscularly every month. Oral
replacement is an alternative for
those patients who cannot tolerate intramuscular injections, or
for whom they are impractical.
Because 1% of all ingested cobalamin may be absorbed by passive
diffusion, cobalamin
requirements can be satisfied with oral therapy, even in
patients with pernicious anemia
(Kuzminski, 1998). A daily dose of 1000 μg/day orally will yield
10 μg of absorbed cobalamin,
which exceeds the recommended daily allowance. Sublingual
cobalamin 2000 ug/ day is also
effective and may be superior to IM injections for some patients
(Delpre, 1999). It may be
practical to replenish cobalamin stores first using injections
of cyanocobalamin for 1 week, and
then to maintain patients using a 1000 μg daily oral supplement.
The effectiveness of treatment,
regardless of route, can be confirmed by demonstrating normal
serum or urine methylmalonic acid
levels three to four weeks after beginning B12 replacement.
The management of post gastroplasty neuropathy begins with a
recognition and replacement of
vitamin deficiency, particularly thiamine and B12. However,
vitamin supplementation alone is
rarely successful. A toxic hypothesis is supported by the fact
that some have reported a resolution if the symptoms following reversal of the surgical procedure
whereas nutritional replacement
alone does not.
The management of gluten sensitivity neuropathy is preliminary
given its uncertainty. Further
study of the efficacy of a gluten free diet in patients with
anti-gliadin antibodies and a peripheral
neuropathy is warranted
www.cidpusa.org
www.cidpusa.org/P/ivig.htm
http://www.cidpusa.org/disease.html
http://www.cidpusa.org/Lahore.html
|