|
ENHANCEMENT OF
NORADRENERGIC NEURAL
TRANSMISSION: AN
EFFECTIVE THERAPY OF
MYASTHENIA GRAVIS
A
REPORT ON 52
CONSECUTIVE PATIENTS
JOURNAL OF MEDICINE
Copyright © 2000 by
PJD Publications
Limited
Research
Communications
Westbury, NY
11590-0966 USA
Fuad. Lechin1,2,
Bertha van der Dijs1,2,
Betty
Pardey-Maldonado1,
Eduardo Jahn1,
Vladimir Jimenez1,
Beatriz Orozco1,
Scarlet Baez2
and Marcel E. Lechin3
Sections of 1Neuropharmacology
and 2Clinical
Neurochemistry,
Instituto de
Medicina
Experimental,
Universidad Central
de Venezuela.
3Texas
A & M University,
School of Medicine,
College Station, TX,
USA
Key Words:
Myasthenia gravis
and Th2 immune
disorders,
myasthenia gravis
treatment,
noradrenergic neural
transmission,
sympathetic activity
and autoimmune
disorders, serotonin
and autoimmune
disorders.
Subjects:
Patients with
myasthenia gravis.
Abbreviations:f5HT
= free-serotonin, LC
= locus coeruleus,
MG = myasthenia
gravis, NA =
noradrenergic, SLE =
systemic lupus
erythematous.
Abstract
Neurochemical,
neuroautonomic and
neuropharmacological
assessments carried
out on all our
myasthenia gravis
(MG) patients showed
that they presented
a neural sympathetic
deficit plus
excessive
adrenal-sympathetic
activity. These
abnormalities were
registered during
the basal
(supine-resting)
state, as well as
after several stress
tests (orthostasis,
exercise, oral
glucose and
buspirone). In
addition, MG
patients showed
increased levels of
free-serotonin
(f5HT) in the
plasma, supposedly
associated with the
increased platelet
aggregability which
we found in all MG
patients. As the
above trio of
neurochemical
disorders (low
noradrenergic-activity
+ high
adrenergic-activity
+ increased f-5HT
plasma levels) is
known to favor Th-1
immunosuppression +
Th-2 predominance,
we outlined a
neuropharmacological
strategy for
reverting the above
neurochemical
disorder. This
treatment provoked
sudden (acute), and
late sustained
improvements. Acute
effects have been
attributed to the
increase of alpha-1
activity at the
spinal motoneuron
level. Late
improvements always
paralleled a
significant
normalization of
immunological
disorders. Complete
normalization was
registered only in
non-thymectomized MG
patients.
Introduction
In a preliminary,
report we published
the successful
therapeutic results
obtained in eight
myasthenia gravis
(MG) patients
receiving
neuropharmacological
treatment (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al., 1997a). In
the present study,
we presented the
results obtained in
a series of 52
consecutive MG
patients given the
same therapy aimed
at enhancing
noradrenergic (NA)
neural transmission.
The rationale of our
neuropharmacological
approach rests on
two fundamental
findings: first, all
our MG patients
showed a
neurochemical
deficiency of
central and
peripheral
noradrenergic (NA)
activity (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al., 1985a,
1985b, 1990a, 1990b,
1995a, 1995b, 1996a,
1996b, 1996c,
1996e), and second,
those MG patients
who had not
previously been
submitted to
surgical and/or
chemical
immunosuppression
all showed an
immunological Th-2
disorder, confirming
data obtained by
many other
researchers
(Barnard, Mahon
et al., 1996;
Faxvaag, Espevik
et al., 1995;
Romagnani, 1996). We
decided, therefore,
to attempt a
two-pronged
neuropharmacological
therapy addressed to
increasing NA
neural, but not
adrenal, sympathetic
activity. This
decision was adopted
for the following
reasons: it has been
exhaustively
demonstrated that NA
neural activity
stimulates the
immune system, in
particular
macrophages and Th-1
cytokines, whereas
adrenal glands
sympathetic activity
displays opposite
effects and, in
addition, is
associated with
excessive humoral
immunity (Th-2
profile) and Th-2
cytokines (Kouassi,
Li et al.,
1990; Madden,
Moynihan et al.,
1994b; Spengler,
Allen et al.,
1990).
Neuropharmacological
manipulations were
designed to
stimulate the locus
coeruleus (LC) NA
neurons.
Further-more,
considering that all
our MG patients
showed high free
serotonin in plasma
rather than in
platelets (raised
f-5HT plasma
levels), possibly
associated with the
increased platelet
aggregability that
all them presented,
we assumed that
eliminating the
well-known Th-1
immunosuppressant
effects of f-5HT
would aid in
reverting the
autoimmune disorders
underlying MG
disease (Fuchs,
Campbell et al.,
1988; Jackson,
Walker et al.,
1998; Paegelow,
Werner et al.,
1985; Sternberg,
Wedner et al.,
1987; Walker and
Codd, 1985; Warren,
Kane et al.,
1990) also included
into the Th-2
autoimmune diseases
(MokhtarianShirazian
et al.,
1993).
It has been
exhaustively
demonstrated that
peripheral neural
sympathetic activity
reflects, and is
closely and
positively
correlated with,
central
noradrenergic (NA)
neural transmission,
which is ruled by
the locus coeruleus
(LC) or
A6-NA-neuronal
pontine group
(Bamshad, Kay Song
et al., 1999;
Elam, Thoren et
al., 1986;
Esler, Wallin et
al., 1991; Lake,
Ziegler et al.,
1976; Lambert, Kaye
et al., 1998;
Thompson Wallin
et al., 1998;
Ziegler, Lake et
al., 1977).
During normal basal
conditions, adrenal
glands supply some
20% to the
circulating pool of
plasma NA, as
expressed by the
NA/Ad ratio
³
5 (Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1985a, 1985b, 1990a,
1990b, 1995a, 1995b,
1996a, 1996b, 1996c,
1996e). Thus,
increases or
decreases of this
NA/Ad ratio parallel
enhancement or
reduction of the
contribution by
noradrenergic neural
transmission to the
global sympathetic
activity. According
to the above, the
neuropharmacological
strategy we outlined
in order to enhance
central NA and
peripheral neural
sympathetic
activities was based
on three types of
central acting
drugs: 1) amino acid
precursors of NA
(Musgrave, Bachmann
et al., 1985;
Musso, Brenci et
al., 1997); 2)
drugs which are able
to trigger
enhancement of the
LC-NA neuronal
firing as, for
instance, alpha2
antagonists
(Rodriguez-Manso,
1999; Verwaerde,
Tran et al.,
1997; Yan, Jobe
et al., 1993),
and drugs like
buspirone that
trigger the firing
of NA neurons and,
in addition, inhibit
serotonergic (5-HT)
neurons and
disinhibit NA
neurons from
5HT-bridling axons
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1997b, 1998a;
Piercey, Smith et
al., 1994); 3)
drugs which are able
to inhibit the
re-uptake of NA by
axon terminals and
thus prolong the
action of NA at the
synaptic level
(desipramine,
protryptiline,
nortryptiline,
doxepin) (Esler,
Wallin et al.,
1991; Lechin, van
der Dijs et al.,
1979b; Sugrue, 1983;
Yan, Jobe et al.,
1993). Finally,
during the last 6
months we frequently
prescribed adrafinil
or modafinil
(alpha-1 agonists)
which are very
useful substitutes
for NA (Anderson and
Harvey, 1988; Binder
and Powers, 1999;
Brustein and
Rossignol, 1999;
Duteil Rambert et
al., 1990; Gerin
and Privat, 1998;
Jabre and
Salzsieder, 1999;
Fishman, Feigembaum
et al., 1983;
Sokoloff, Siegel
et al., 1999;
Wada, Hasegawa et
al., 1997)
particularly in some
cases where central
NA neurons are
diminished because
of aging. It is very
widely known that
LC-NA neurons
diminish with aging
(Arranz, Blennow
et al., 1996)
and so elder
patients may have a
limited response
capacity to
stimulating drugs.
Although other
pharmacological
manipulations would
include drugs that
reduce free
serotonin in the
plasma (f-5HT) like
tianeptine, (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al., 1998b;
1998c) the results
obtained with this
tool are not
presented in this
report. In effect,
f-5HT has been shown
to block muscular
ACh-receptors and so
it should play some
etiopathogenic role
in MG disease, not
only by suppressing
Th-1 immunity but
also by interfering
with neuromuscular
transmission
(Grassi, 1999).
Patients and Methods
Patients
The protocol used in
this study was
approved by the
Ethical Committee of
Funda-IME)
(Fundación de apoyo
al Instituto de
Medicina
Experimental),
Universidad Central
de Venezuela,
Caracas, Venezuela.
All patients signed
an informed consent.
This was an open
study carried out on
MG patients
recruited from
subjects arising
from neurology
departments in
hospitals in
Venezuela and other
countries. All these
patients were
referred to our
institute because
they either did not
obtain significant
improvement or show
progressive
impairment. Up to
the present, we have
enrolled 61 MG
patients. However,
in this study we
included 52 patients
only. The remaining
nine patients
started our
therapeutic trial
but did not follow
it for various
reasons: two because
of emergency
hospitalization
early in the trial;
five out-of-town
patients because of
financial
difficulties (due to
travel expenses
despite the fact
that our trial,
blood tests and
drugs were free of
charge); and two
patients who only
attended our
institute once. Six
patients had
received prior
treatment in other
countries (Columbia
Presbyterian
Hospital in New
York, Jackson
Memorial Hospital in
Miami, John's
Hopkins Hospital in
Baltimore, Posbus
Hospital in the
Republic of South
Africa, Mexico City
Hospital and the San
José Hospital in
Costa Rica).
Forty-six patients
were diagnosed and
previously treated
in Venezuela:
Hospital
Universitario in
Caracas (24),
Hospital Vargas in
Caracas (4),
Hospital Ruiz y Paez
in Ciudad Bolivar
(7), Hospital
Central in Valencia
(4), Hospital
Universitario in
Maracaibo (2),
Hospital Guerra
Méndez in Valencia
(2), Hospital
Militar in Caracas
(3).
All patients were
diagnosed according
to clinical
features,
electromyography
findings and
edrophonium testing.
Data referring to
clinical features
are shown in Tables
I to V.
Methods
Neurochemical
Investigation
Plasma
neurotransmitters
were dosified during
basal
(supine-resting)
condition and after
several stress
tests: orthostasis,
exercise (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al. 1995a,
1995b, 1996b, 1996d,
1996e, 1997c), oral
glucose (Lechin, van
der Dijs et al.,
1991, 1992, 1993),
and buspirone
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1997b, 1998a)
according to
procedures explained
in previously
published papers.
Blood samples for
immunological
investigations were
processed and
transferred to
Laboratorios BIOCELL
220, C.A (Caracas,
Venezuela) and for
some special tests
to SPECIALTY
LABORATORIES,
(Michigan Av., Santa
Monica, CA, USA).
These routine
investigations
included:
antinuclear
antibodies (ANA),
cellular immune
dysfunction
evaluation, CFIDS,
AH5O, CH5O, dsDNA
autoantibodies,
F-actin
autoantibodies,
humoral immune
evaluation, NK cell
evaluation, platelet
auto-antibodies,
Scl-70
autoantibodies, AChR
autoantibodies,
striational
autoantibodies,
anti-JO-1, C3/C4,
and lymphocyte
subpopulations (CD3,
CD4, CD5, CD8, CD19,
CD2O, CD45RA,
CD45RO),
immune-globulins
(IgA, IgG, IgM,
IgE).
Clinical Assessment
We modified the MG
scoring system by
Osserman and
Genking, (1966) by
inverting average
muscle scoring (AMS)
(Mantegazza Antozzi
et al., 1988;
Mendell and
Florence, 1990)
which provided the
numerical score for
muscular strength
(ocular, facial,
abdominal and
extremity muscles),
and chewing,
swallowing,
phonation and
respiration.
Electromyographical
parameters plus
clinical ratings are
expressed together.
Scores were verified
fortnightly and
graded in
percentages.
Neurophamacological
Therapy
Restoration of
central and
peripheral NA
(alpha-adrenergic)
activity:
a) Aminoacid
precursors
(L-phenylalanine,
L-tyrosine), 50 mg
before breakfast.
b) Inhibitor of
NA re-uptake
(desipramine), 25 mg
before breakfast.
c) NA-releasing
agent + suppressor
of serotonergic
activity (buspirone)
l0-20 mg at 10 am +
beta-adrenergic
blocking agent
(propranolol 10-20
mg).
d) Alpha-1
agonists: adrafinil
(150-300 mg) or
modafinil (100-200
mg) at 10 a.m.
Because this
noradrenergic
(alpha-adrenergic)
activation usually
induces insomnia,
the treatment was
not administered in
afternoon hours.
When this side
effect was observed,
a small dose of
5-hydroxytryptophan
(25 mg) was
administered before
supper, in order to
counterbalance
excessive
hyper-noradrenergic
induced activity.
Five-hydroxytryptophan,
a serotonin
precursor, can be
added to a small
dose (15 mg) of
mirtazapine
(Remeron),
administered before
bed. This drug
stimulates the
release from central
neuronal circuits of
NA and 5HT,
neurotransmitters
both needed to
facilitate a normal
slow wave sleep
(SWS). All
benzodiazepines
and/or gaba-mimetic
drugs were banned
because they provoke
strong suppression
of noradrenaline +
dopamine (DA) +
serotonin release
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1994).
Considering that
late-onset MG and
thymoma patients
show antibodies to
striated muscle
antigens (Aarli,
1999), a condition
frequently leading
to muscular atrophy,
we administered
growth hormone (4 IU
weekly) to some of
these patients in
order to provoke
muscle fiber
regeneration
(Daugaard, Laustsen
et al.,
1998). This
additional
therapeutic tool
proved be highly
effective in two
cases.
Taking into account
that f-5HT blocks
the fetal more
potently than the
adult muscle
acetylcholine
receptor (Grassi,
1999), we
administered small
doses of tianeptine
(a serotonin
enhancer of platelet
uptake - 6.75 mg
each other day)
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1998b; 1998c).
Analytical Methods
Platelet aggregation
was determined at 0
min and 5 min only,
employing the
adenosine
diphosphate method
described by Born
(1962).
For plasma NA, Ad,
DA, and 5HT (p-5HT +
f-5HT) readers are
referred to papers
previously published
by our research
group. These
references give
details dealing with
orthostasis,
exercise, (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al., 1995a,
1995b, 1996e), oral
glucose (Lechin, van
der Dijs et al.,
1992, 1993) and
buspirone (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al., 1997b,
1998a) stress tests.
Results
Assessment of the
therapeutic effects
resulting from our
neuropharmacological
approach should
properly be based on
clinical, EMG and
immunological
parameters. However,
we will also comment
on some
neurochemical and
neuroautonomic
induced effects (see
Tables I to V).
Clinical Findings:
All MG patients
showed a highly
significant and
sustained reduction
of symptoms during
acute (£
6 days) and late
(weeks and months)
periods after
starting the
neuropharmacological
therapy. Patients
registered no
relapses, no MG
crises, nor new
plasmapheresis after
initiation of our
treatment.
Immunosuppressant
drugs were totally
eliminated.
Suppression of
steroids was
acomplished
progressively.
Mestinon was also
progressively
omitted attaining
until reaching
complete or highly
significant
reduction. The total
suppression of
Mestinon was
effected in all
non-thymectomized
patients and in
three thymectomized
cases. In the other
thymectomized
patients, Mestinon
was reduced to a
minimum.
Immunological
Findings
Increased CD5+B
self-reactive and
CD8 (suppressor)
lymphocytes were
registered in all
patients. They also
showed immunological
abnormalities
consistent with the
Th-2 profile
(increased NK-cells,
decreased NK-cell
cytotoxicity,
increased IgG and/or
IgM plasma levels),
increased CD45RO
(memory T cells).
These immunological
abnormalities
disappeared in all
non-thymectomized
patients after
sustained
neuropharmacological
treatment (±
3 months).
Thymectomized
patients and some
who had received
prolonged
immunotherapy
presented an
atypical profile of
the immune disorder
(see Tables IV and
V). Most such
abnormalities did
not disappear
despite the
significant and
sustained clinical
improvement shown by
these patients.
Moreover, the
thymectomized and
immunosuppressed
patients registered
a lower recovery
than that shown by
the
non-thymectomized or
non-immunosuppressed
patients.
Twenty-four out of
the 27
non-thymectomized
patients showed
increased levels of
ACh-receptor
autoantibodies
before
neuropharmaco-logical
treatment. After
therapy, 20 of those
24 patients showed
normalization or a
great reduction of
this parameter. On
the other hand, an
erratic response was
observed in MG
patients previously
submitted to
surgical or
drug-induced
immunosuppression.
Seven out of the 25
thymectomized
patients showed
Scl-70
auto-antibodies
[usually registered
in systemic lupus
erythematous (SLE)
patients]. Only one
patient showed
increased
anti-striated muscle
autoantibodies plus
increased levels of
ACh-R
autoantibodies,
before and after
therapy. He was a
38-year-old male
whose myasthenia
gravis symptoms
began in 1985. He
was affected by
hepatitis during
childhood. He was
rated as a II-a MG
patient. The
electromyography
test was positive
for MG.
Thymectomized on
Sept. 20, 1993, he
was prescribed
Mestinon therapy
which he took for
six years. He
accepted neither
steroids nor
immunosuppressant
drugs. We performed
immunological
investigations on
March 3/99, May
18/99, and June
22/99 with similar
immune abnormalities
(reduced CD4/CD8
ratio plus increased
T virgin cells).
These abnormalities
were found on all
three occasions.
Neither
immunological nor
serological
abnormalities
disappeared despite
his clinical
improvement with
neuropharmaco-logical
therapy.
Neuropharmacological,
neurochemical and
autonomic test
results were
normalized in all
patients after
completing our
therapy. These tests
paralleled clinical
improvement.
Neurochemical
Findings
All patients showed
very low NA/Ad ratio
plus high f-5HT
plasma levels before
treatment. After
treatment, all
neurochemical
abnormalities were
reverted (see Tables
IV and V). The NA/Ad
plasma ratio reached
normal or greater
than normal values (³
5). This NA/Ad ratio
showed further
increases after
orthostasis,
exercise, oral
glucose and/or
buspirone challenge.
Noradrenaline but
not adrenaline
increased during
these tests. The
abnormal diastolic
blood pressure (DBP)
and heart rate (HR)
responses returned
to normal after one
month of
neuropharmacological
therapy.
Normalization of
these autonomic
parameters depends
on the disappearance
of adrenal gland
hyperresponsiveness
+ recovery of
central sympathetic
(neural) activity
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1995a, 1995b,
1996e).
Discussion
The results obtained
from the present
study ratified
findings showing
that myasthenia
gravis is an
immunologic disorder
presenting a Th-2
profile of immunity
(Jaretzki, 1997;
Karussis, Lehmann
et al., 1994;
Kouassi, Li et
al., 1990;
Mokhtarian,
Shirazian et al.,
1993; Ragheb and
Lissak, 1993; Talal,
Dauphinee et al.,
1998; Yi and
Lefvert, 1993;
Zhang, Yu et al.,
1997). The results
also confirmed that
thymectomy is
followed by an
undefined
disturbance of the
immune system
(Gerli, Paganelli
et al., 1999).
This finding has
been demonstrated by
many researchers who
reported that a high
percentage of
thymectomized
patients developed
any of several types
of autoimmune
diseases, frequently
systemic lupus
erythematous (SLE)
(Jaretzki, 1997;
Karussis, Lehmann
et al., 1994;
Talal, Dauphinee
et al., 1998; Yi
and Lefvert, 1993;
Zhang, Yu et al.,
1997). Finally, the
present study showed
that MG patients
present a deficiency
of central and
peripheral
noradrenergic (NA)
activity and that
neuropharmacological
manipulations
addressed to
enhancing neural
transmission of this
system are able to
attain clinical
remission as well as
reversion of the
Th-1 < Th-2
imbalance (Nicholson
and Kuchroo, 1996).
Our results showed
that although the
onset of clinical
improvement occurred
rapidly (< one
week), immunological
normalization took
months (2-3 months).
When this stage of
late improvement was
obtained, doses of
drugs were reduced.
With regard to this,
we observed that MG
patients taking high
Mestinon doses
responded slowly to
our
neuropharmacological
therapy. This
finding may be
associated with the
fact that
acetylcholinesterase
inhibitors provoke
down-regulation of
ACh-receptors
(Tiedt, Albuquerque
et al.,
1978). We also found
that MG patients
taking Mestinon at
night responded more
slowly than those
taking only diurnal
Mestinon. We
inferred that these
patients do not
sleep well because
of a lack of
muscular relaxation
induced by the
sustained enhanced
neuromuscular
nocturnal
ACh-activity. This
factor would
contribute to
aggravating the
diurnal muscular
fatigue they usually
presented.
Furthermore,
considering that
normalization of
immunity as well as
central
noradrenergic
activity occurs
during sleep, mainly
during phases III
and IV of slow wave
sleep (SWS) when
growth hormone
secretion peaks, it
becomes clear why
normalization of the
sleep pattern is
necessary to the
recovery of all
autoimmune diseases
(Kelley, 1989).
It has long been
known that NA
facilitates
neuromuscular
transmission and
muscle contraction
(Binder and Powers,
1999; Brustein and
Rossignol, 1999;
Bukcharaeva, Kim
et al., 1999;
Duteil, Rambert
et al., 1990;
Fishman, Feigembaum
et al., 1983;
Gerin and Privat,
1998; Jabre and
Salzsieder, 1999;
Kernell, Bakels
et al., 1999;
Sokoloff, Siegel
et al., 1999;
Sugrue, 1983). The
sudden (acute)
clinical improvement
registered in all
our MG patients
during
neuropharmacological
therapy should be
attributed to the
effect of NA
released at spinal
motoneuron levels.
At this level, NA
excites alpha-1
post-synaptic
receptors which
facilitate muscular
activity. As is
amplied known, the
CNS controls posture
and movements
through the
activation of spinal
motoneurons which
receive
noradrenergic
excitatory and
serotonergic
modulatory axons
from medullary and
pontine nuclei.
Spinal motoneurons
receive thousands of
presynaptic
excitatory (NA) and
inhibitory (5HT)
axons which
distribute
throughout their
dendritic trees.
Noradrenaline
excites alpha-1
receptors whereas
serotonin, acting at
5HT-1a receptors,
modulates NA effects
at the spinal
motoneurons level.
In addition, NA
synchronizes the
evoked quantal
release at
neuromuscular
junctions
(Bukcharaeva, Kim
et al., 1999).
Noradrenergic axons
innervating spinal
motoneurons arise
from the locus
coeruleus (LC) also
called A6-NA and
A5-NA cell groups
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1989). Serotonergic
axons innervating
spinal motoneurons
arise from the
medullary raphe
pallidus and raphe
obscurus nuclei.
Alpha-2
antagonist drugs
excite motoneurons
by increasing the
firing activity of
NA neurons which
release
noradrenaline from
axons innervating
spinal motoneurons.
Similar effects are
displayed by
buspirone. This drug
at low doses
(similar to those
employed in anxiety
patients) may exert
a dual effect on
spinal motoneurons:
an excitatory effect
by increasing the
release of NA from
noradrenergic axons,
and an indirect
polysynaptic effect
secondary to the
reduction of
activity of the
medullary raphe
nuclei which possess
5HT-1a inhibitory
autoreceptors
(Lechin, van der
Dijs et al.,
1979a). The
short-lived effect
of the alpha2
antagonists-induced
release of
noradrenaline can be
prolonged by the
addition of an
inhibitor of NA
re-uptake at
synaptic level
(desipramine,
nortryptiline,
protryptiline,
doxepin, etc.)
(Lechin et al.,
1979b).
According to all the
above, it becomes
clear why
neuropharmacological
therapy addressed to
enhancing central NA
neural transmission
triggers an acute
and sudden
improvement of
muscular strength in
MG patients. This
phenomenon has been
known since the
1980s decade to
neurophysiologists
familiar with the
findings obtained in
spinal cats.
Adrafinil and
modafinil (two alpha1
agonists) trigger
acetylcholine
release from motor
nerves and
facilitate
neuromuscular
transmission by a
selective action at
presynpatic alpha1
receptors located at
that level (Wessler,
1992).
The late and
sustained
improvement
registered in our
study would reflect
the role played by
the excitatory
effect of
noradrenergic
innervation at
lymphoid organs and
the
immunosuppressant
effects displayed by
plasma serotonin
(f-5HT). Scientific
literature dealing
with these two
immunomodulating
factors is too
extensive to be
covered in this
discussion. By way
of example, however,
we will cite some
studies: Ackerman,
Felten et al.,
1987; Bencsics,
Sershen et al.,
1997; Besedowsky,
del Rey et al.,
1979; Felten and
Olschowka, 1987;
Felten, Felten et
al., 1987;
Livnat, Felten et
al., 1985;
Lorton, Hewitt et
al., 1990; Tang,
Shankar et al.,
1999; Thyaga-Rajan,
Madden et al.,
1999.
It has been
exhaustively
demonstrated that
the regions in which
lymphocytes T cells
reside, and through
which they
recirculate, receive
direct sympathetic
neural input.
Therefore, the
immune system can be
considered
“hard-wired” to the
brain. Chemical
sympathectomy of
adult mice resulted
in reduced antibody
responses to
T-dependent
antigens. The
interaction between
sympathetic NA nerve
fibers and cells of
the immune system
has been shown
through the
distribution of
tyrosine hydrolase
(TH+)
nerve fibers among
lymphocytes and
macrophages in
lymphoid organs, the
expression of
adrenoceptors on
cells of the immune
system, and the
immunomodulatory
effects of NA. In
old rats, a
conspicuous decline
in NA innervation
and NA contents is
observed in the
splenic white pulp
as well as in the
cell bodies in
superior
celiac-mesenteric
ganglia that provide
preganglionic
sympathetic
innervation to the
spleen (Arnason,
1993; Carlson, Fox
et al., 1997;
Madden. Felten et
al., 1994a;
Roszman and Carlson,
1991). Paralleling
these alterations in
sympathetic NA
neuronal activity is
an age-related loss
of T cell mediated
immune responses,
including reduced T
cell proliferation
and IL-2 production
by antigen- and
mitogen-stimulated
lymphocytes.
Treatment of these
rats with drugs
inducing
noradrenergic
regeneration and re-innervation
reverted the rats’
immune abnormalities
(Tang, Shankar et
al., 1999;
Thyaga-Rajan, Madden
et al.,
1999). Noradrenergic
innervation of the
spleen is
responsible for a
significant increase
of gamma-interferon,
IL-2 and tumor
necrosis factor
alpha, the three
Th-1 cytokines, and
a lowering of IL-4,
IL-5 and IL-10 (TH-2
cytokines)
production (Carlson,
Fox et al.,
1997; Madden,
Moynihan et al.,
1994b; Spengler,
Allen et al.,
1990). Other
evidence showed that
elevated plasma NA
concentrations
increased the level
of Th-1 cytokines (Kappel,
Poulsen et al.,
1998; Ross, Williams
et al.,
1987). These and
other findings
demonstrate that the
noradrenergic
innervation of bone
marrow is
functionally dynamic
and is responsive to
central activation.
Furthermore, these
results lend
credence to the
premise that neural
mechanisms
participate in
regulating
lymphopoietic
cellular events.
Data demonstrates
that adrenaline (Ad)
suppresses Th-1
immunity and
stimulates Th-2
cytokines
(Cook-Mills, Cohen
et al., 1995;
Crary, Houser et
al., 1983;
Cunnick, Lysle et
al., 1990;
Ernstrom and
Sandberg, 1973;
Felsner, Hofer et
al., 1995;
Kouassi, Li et
al., 1990; Tvede,
Kappel et al.,
1994; Van Tits,
Michel et al.,
1990). These effects
are mediated by
beta-adrenoceptors
in human
lymphocytes. Beta-adrenoceptors
also mediate NK-
activity (Kappel,
Tvede et al.,
1991; Schedlowski,
Hosch et al.,
1996; Vredevoe,
Moser et al.,
1995)
The role of
circulating free
serotonin (f-5HT)
has also been
exhaustively
investigated. For
instance,
macrophages possess
a 5HT-uptake system,
the kinetic
properties of which
make them sensitive
to changes in plasma
levels of 5HT
(Fuchs, Campbell
et al., 1988;
Jackson, Walker
et al., 1998;
Sternberg, Wedner
et al., 1987;
Young and Matthews,
1995). In addition,
it has been shown
that serotonin
stimulates Th-2
lymphokine secretion
(Paegelow, Werner
et al., 1985).
It is known that NA
alters the capacity
of platelets to
sequester and/or
catabolize 5HT, thus
regulating its
physiologically
active pool in the
plasma (Fuchs,
Campbell et al.,
1988; Walker and
Codd, 1985; Warren,
Kane et al.,
1990). Thus, through
its ability to
regulate plasma
levels of 5HT, an
immunosuppressive
amine with access to
macrophages, the
nervous system can
influence cells
involved in antigen
recognition. In
aging rodents and
humans, the central
noradrenergic
deficit is
associated with a
decreased platelet
affinity for 5HT and
an increased plasma
content of 5HT. In
addition to the
above, the increased
f-5HT we registered
in our MG patients
would also be
associated with the
raised adrenaline
plasma levels they
presented. This
latter factor would
be responsible for
the increased
platelet
aggregability we
registered in all
our MG patients
(Larsson, Hjemdahl
et al.,
1989). Finally, it
has been known for
several years that
pharmacological
enhancement of 5HT
metabolism
suppresses the
immune response
in vivo. This
immunosuppression
occurs peripherally,
not centrally
(Walker and Codd,
1985).
Free serotonin in
plasma should also
play some important
role in triggering
myasthenic crisis
since we were able
to accelerate the
recovery of several
MG patients affected
by this severe
complication by
administering
tianeptine to them.
This finding is
consistent with the
bronchial
constriction effect
exerted by f-5HT in
asthmatic patients
who were also
dramatically
improved by this
serotonin-enhancing
uptaker drug (Lechin,
van der Dijs et
al., 1996b,
1998b, 1998c). |