In a
letter this week to CDC
Director Julie
Gerberding, committee
members warned that they
expect her to protect
the scientist,
Christopher De Rosa.
"The agency's conduct
has called into question
its ability to
investigate public
health hazards
accurately and
appropriately in the
future," wrote the
chairman and two
subcommittee chairmen
from the House Committee
on Science and
Technology in a letter
Wednesday to Gerberding.
"Apparently in
retaliation, Dr. De Rosa
was removed from his
post and given a job ...
that appears to include
no real
responsibilities," the
letter said.
CDC spokesman Glen
Nowak said Friday the
agency has not
suppressed any science,
nor has it retaliated
against De Rosa. "The
integrity of CDC's
science is paramount to
everything we do," Nowak
said.
De Rosa had been head
of the division of
toxicology and
environmental medicine
in CDC's Agency for
Toxic Substances and
Disease Registry since
1992. He was removed
from that job last fall
and assigned the title
of "special assistant."
Though CDC said De
Rosa was simply
reassigned, he said in
an interview that he's
been demoted. De Rosa
said the public should
be concerned about
what's transpired.
"The very people
they're looking to for
answers have been
censored," he said.
At issue is whether
the agency intentionally
delayed or avoided
examining the long-term
cancer threat posed by
formaldehyde fumes in
trailers purchased by
the Federal Emergency
Management Agency to
house victims of the
August 2005 hurricane.
FEMA initially said air
quality in the trailers
was safe if they were
properly ventilated.
Formaldehyde is a
colorless gas with a
pungent smell. It is
used in the production
of plywood and resins.
Some studies have linked
exposure to formaldehyde
with nose and throat
cancer.
The committee also is
investigating whether
CDC abruptly stopped
publication of another
report involving De
Rosa, detailing
"disturbing potential
health issues" in the
Great Lakes region of
the U.S., the letter
said. The report
examined areas with
environmental pollution
and found elevated
levels of certain
cancers and other health
problems but did not
make any
cause-and-effect link.
"I want to find out
what really happened,"
said Rep. Brad Miller
(D-N.C.), chairman of
the Subcommittee on
Investigations and
Oversight, Friday
evening.
It's the latest
incident involving
allegations that CDC's
scientific findings on
environmental issues are
being watered down.
In October, another
committee investigated
the White House's
involvement in the
cutting of nearly seven
pages of information
about the health
consequences of climate
change. The deletions
were from written
testimony Gerberding had
planned to give to
Congress. Gerberding,
however, was adamant she
had not been censored.
Nowak said CDC's
actions were focused on
maintaining high
standards of science. He
said the Great Lakes
report was pulled from
publication because
parts of it were
misleading and didn't
meet standards of
scientific rigor. The
committee is
investigating whether
agency managers
"intentionally
circumvented" De Rosa in
an initial review of
potential dangers
associated with the
trailers.
FEMA wanted ATSDR to
look only at the health
effects of short-term
formaldehyde exposure --
defined as less than two
weeks. Yet many Katrina
residents have lived in
the trailers for months
and years, the committee
said in its letter.
De Rosa, the
committee's letter said,
already had raised
questions about the
long-term health effects
and agency managers knew
he would insist the
report not be confined
to short-term effects.
Formaldehyde is a
suspected carcinogen
that has no safe level
set for long-term
exposure, the letter
said.
"De Rosa was then
specifically and
consciously excluded in
the health assessment,"
said Miller, referring
to information provided
to the committee.
Miller said
information reviewed by
the committee indicates
FEMA's requests of CDC
were driven by concerns
about legal liability,
not public health.
FEMA officials
declined to be
interviewed Friday. But
in written statements,
they have said the
agency didn't ignore,
hide or manipulate
research. They said the
health and safety of
hurricane victims was
their top priority at
all times.
Nowak, the CDC
spokesman, said the
agency initially focused
solely on short-term
effects because that's
what FEMA asked CDC to
look at. But he said the
agency later issued a
supplemental report with
information about
long-term health
effects.
"Nobody was ignoring
the fact that
formaldehyde had
longer-term health
consequences," Nowak
said. The agency has
been sampling the air
quality in more than 500
trailers in Louisiana
and Mississippi and is
now in the process of
analyzing the data.
Congressional
investigators, however,
said CDC only amended
the report to include
long-term exposure
warnings eight months
later -- after De Rosa
"persistently demanding"
they be included.
De Rosa said Friday
that he raised his
concerns about
formaldehyde, the Great
Lakes report and other
issues through proper
channels within the CDC.
"It's sort of like
speaking truth to
authority. I knew I was
doing it at my peril,"
he said.
Then, in what
investigators said was
apparently retaliation,
De Rosa was removed from
his managerial job and
in October given an
"unsatisfactory" job
performance assessment.
Before, De Rosa said, he
had received good to
excellent ratings.